Notes from my time with about 100 McGill students watching tonight's debate.
-Obama already pouncing on AIG's expensive corporate retreat with taxpayer money
-McCain looks very awkward walking around, odd camera angles make it worse
-Who would you want as Treasury secretary? "Not you, Tom [Brokaw]" - McCain WTF?
-"You're not interested in seeing politicians pointing fingers" - Obama
-Too much talking point time is being allowed between questions
-McCain finally looking at Obama! Hey yea he's there! The rest of us already knew, though.
-CNN voting tracker: Swing women love Obama. Lucky guy
-I'm getting tired of hearing about earmarks...there were tons in the bailout package and neither of you seemed to care
-Obama on sacrifice: change energy habits, join peace core
-Obama prefers a scalpel to a hatchet for the budget...but at this point, would people prefer the hatchet?
-Obama: mr smooth "The straight talk express has lost a wheel"
-Numbers, numbers, numbers. 10 billion for this, 200 million for that. Does it even mean anything to the average voter?
-McCain is (thank god) on the right side of the climate change debate, but is Palin?
-Nice Obama line (paraphrase) - Congress hasn't done shit for climate change in 30 years, and John was there for 26 of them. Cheers at McGill
-Like numbers, i think people are tired of hearing how these senators voted and how many times they did it. Saying Obama never created legislation to do something is barely meaningful since he was only a full time senator for 2 years, and saying McCain voted 353 times for that is barely meaningful since hes been in the senate for decades.
-Obama owns the health care debate. Send a thank you card to Hillary
-McCain introduced some "crossing state lines" argument, and Obama throws it out the window.
-McCain shouldn't say he's nervous about anything...even if it's Obama's plans...its not helping the old guy image
-Obama: Health Care is a Right. I don't agree, but its the right thing for him to say.
-Still on health care, obama cites his Mother's death and nails McCain on S-CHIP. Why doesn't McCain ever talk about his cancer? Oh i know, the old guy image agian, and don't forget this image from a possible future: "On this tragic day, Vice President Palin takes the oath of office, and becomes the 45th President..."
-McCain: America is the greatest force for good in the world. Jeers from McGill students
-Not sure why Obama is calling McCain a big spender
-Obama: we could be with the world in Darfur intervention
-McCain still acts like the Iraq war started in January 2007
-Pakistan - Obama says central front in war on terror is Afghanistan/Pakistan. CORRECT
-McCain: Obama likes to "talk loudly and carry a big stick" in foreign policy. ARE YOU KIDDING? If anyone is the "bring it on" type, its McCain.
-McCain is unwilling to take risky action in Pakistan to get Bin Laden. Didnt he say he wanted to follow Bin Laden to the gates of hell?
-FINALLY!! Obama brings up McCain's "Bomb Bomb Bomb, Bomb Bomb Iran" joke from early in his campaign. By the way, as I remember it, it was not a conversation with a fellow veteran, it was at a town hall campaign stop with cameras rolling.
-McCain only has old worn out jokes
-Interesting idea - Obama cites energy independence as a way to combat russian aggression.
-Awesome last question: What dont you know and how will you learn it - Obama should mention how he would fill his cabinet with strong opposing voices instead of yesmen, in case he is not an expert on the problem theyre dealing with.
-Too bad neither of them answered the question'
-LOL McCain wanders in front of Brokaw's teleprompter!
-Debate winner is impossible to determine objectively. Why bother.